Two New Businesses Open in Downtown Hanover, Honoring Family Legacy and Community Tradition

General News ArticleCommunityPress Release

Hanover, PA — On Friday, April 3, 2026, Main Street Hanover proudly celebrated the opening of two new businesses in downtown Hanover: Tommy Johns’ Tavern and Timeless Betty. Both establishments bring fresh energy to the district while honoring deep family roots and personal legacies.

Located at 15 Center Square, Tommy Johns’ Tavern marks the transformation of the historic Hotel Hanover into a full-service restaurant and bar with seating for up to 150 guests. For third-generation owner Tommy Hufnagle III, the renovation represents a long-held dream and a continuation of a family legacy spanning more than 50 years.
The tavern’s name pays tribute to three generations of Thomas John Hufnagles, Senior, Junior, and III, who have each played a role in shaping the business and its place in the community. Originally opened in 1963 as a pool hall by Thomas John Hufnagle Sr., the establishment evolved over decades into a beloved local gathering space. Today, Tommy Johns’ Tavern blends that rich history with modern hospitality.
“At Tommy Johns’ Tavern, history isn’t just on our walls, it’s in our blood,” said Hufnagle. “We are committed to honoring our legacy by prioritizing people, delivering quality food and service, and creating a welcoming atmosphere where every guest feels like a regular.”
The newly renovated space offers a menu featuring hand-patted burgers, hand-cut fries, never-frozen wings, and a carefully poured Guinness, all served in an environment that reflects both tradition and contemporary comfort.
Tommy Johns’ Tavern hours are:
Monday–Friday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Just steps away at 16 York Street, Timeless Betty offers a different kind of experience, one rooted in nostalgia, style, and personal tribute. Owned by Renee and her husband Jim, the boutique held a soft opening in early March and features a curated collection of vintage clothing, purses, shoes, and antiques.
The shop is named in honor of Renee’s mother, Betty Piper, a beloved former librarian at New Oxford Middle School. Known for her dedication and impact, the school’s courtyard was named after Piper in recognition of her service. Timeless Betty reflects her enduring influence through a carefully selected inventory that celebrates timeless fashion and meaningful pieces.
Timeless Betty is open Thursday through Sunday from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM.
Moriah Tyler, Executive Director of Main Street Hanover, emphasized the significance of both openings to the downtown community.
“What is so exciting is that both businesses honor family loved ones,” said Tyler. “Small businesses are literally the fabric of our communities. These stories, of legacy, remembrance, and passion, are what make downtown Hanover such a special place.”
Main Street Hanover invites the community to visit both Tommy Johns’ Tavern and Timeless Betty to experience their unique offerings and celebrate the continued growth of downtown Hanover.
 
About Tommy Johns Tavern
A beloved local favorite since 1971, Tommy John’s Tavern is a family-owned restaurant and bar located in the heart of Hanover’s Center Square. We pride ourselves on creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere where friends and families can gather to enjoy classic American fare, craft drinks, and a true sense of community.
 
About Timeless Betty
Specializing in vintage clothing, purses, shoes, and antiques. Discover one-of-a-kind pieces, timeless styles, and unique treasures that bring the past to life.

About Main Street Hanover

The mission of Main Street Hanover is to expand the economic capacity of downtown Hanover, thus improving the business environment, enhancing the quality of place, and increasing community synergy.

 

Main Street Hanover is a 501c3 non-profit & proceeds benefit the revitalization of Downtown Hanover.

Two New Businesses Open in Downtown Hanover, Honoring Family Legacy and Community Tradition